Book Review: Silver: Return to Treasure Island by Andrew Motion

August 29, 2012
Article first published asBook Review:Silver: Return to Treasure Islandby Andrew Motionon Blogcritics.

Silver: Return to Treasure Island by Andrew Motion is the novel which continues the adventures of the son of Jim Hawkins, protagonist of Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island. Stevenson’s book was originally published in 1883 and is considered a classic which has influenced many authors, readers and adventure seekers alike.

  • 416 pages
  • Publisher: Crown
  • Language: English
  • ISBN-10: 0307884872

Book Review: Silver: Return to Treasure Island by Andrew MotionMy rating forSilver: Return to Treasure Island4
Buy this book in paper or electronic format*
More Books by Andrew Motion*

Visiting the library one afternoon with my children, my eyes scanned upon the shelf where the librarians earnestly display their newly arrived acquisitions when they caught a glimpse of Silver: Return to Treasure Island by Andrew Motion (Poet Laureate of the United Kingdom from 1999 to 2009). I could hardly believe the audacity, the gull, some might say the chutzpah, of attempting to recreate the magic I remember so fondly from my childhood.
How dare he? Of course I had to pick it up.

A year ago I re-read Treasure Island and to my delight I enjoyed it tremendously as an adult. The magic and adventure were all there, even though some realizations hit me (the star of the story is the iconic Long John Silver, not Jim Hawkins) as well as other enlightenment such as the ambiguous immoralities which are lost on an 8 year old boy.

While Treasure Island was a story for boys, about boys, Silver has a touch of romance when Motion weaves a female into the cast (the daughter of Long John Silver, tomboyish if there ever was one). However, this is still a book about boys and Motion kept it for boys but with an interest to girls as well.

The protagonist, Jim Hawkins the son, gains insights into the evil side of humans, much like his father. Young Jim watches people deteriorate into monsters as well as the heroic side of human nature. He watches people sacrifice themselves without understanding why, but gaining that understanding at the end of the novel, much as his father did before him.

The book is flawless for the first 50 pages or so, fabulous details with a wink and smile towards the original (The Hispaniola is a tavern owned by Jim Hawkins, not the ship) and gripping Stevensonian prose. There is a superb scene where young Jim goes to meet the elderly and infirmed Long John Silver, a shadow of the man he used to be, blind and emaciated with a voice which is “like a sword being pulled from its sheath”.

There are several issues with the story, for one the villains are a weakling bunch who cannot shiver a splinter off of Long John’s wooden leg but the ending of the book makes a fun and exciting read. Treasure Island was a YA book before young adults even imagined having a genre (Stevenson wrote it for his 15 year old stepson), but I don’t think Silverbelongs in that genre. The strength of this book lies in its appeal for those who favorably remember being engrossed in Stevenson’s tale, to nostalgically relive a childhood with familiar characters, exciting yarns and a faithful style.
And sometimes isn’t that all we ask from a book?

There are many nods to the Treasure Island in this novel; my favorite however has to be the crow’s nest watchman. The watchman is constantly above all “like a god in his cloud”, gliding down only occasionally and always pointing the way.
His name: Mr. Stevenson – “a Scotsman and a wisp of a fellow”.

So tell me, have you read a sequel to a favorite book by a different author?

Related Reads:
Treasure Island by Robert Louis Stevenson

Jim Hawkins the son grew up in “an atmosphere stained by melancholy” after his mother’s death. His father used his proceeds from the treasure he found 30 years earlier to start an inn/tavern appropriately named The Hispaniola. One day the enchanting Natalie, daughter of his father’s nemesis/friend Long John Silver, rows up to the inn asking young Jim to steal his father’s treasure map. Together they plan to get the rest of the treasure their father’s left behind.

Long John Silver takes care of all the preparations, however being ill and blind he leaves Natalie (disguised a boy named Nat) to represent his interests and Jim representing his father’s. Together with the crew they sail the Silver Nightingale to Treasure Island only to find that the villains their father’s marooned are still alive and prospering with a wrecked slave ship.

Zohar – Man of la Book
Disclaimer: I borrowed this book from the local library.

BOOK BLOGGERS – Have you read Silver: Return to Treasure Island? If so link up your review below:

--- Please like and follow ---


  • JaneGSDecember 13, 2014 at 3:39 pm

    I’ve been meaning to get a copy of Silver myself, but I feel like I have to reread TI first. TI may have been about boys for boys, but I loved it as young reader (maybe because I have four brothers) and remember it fondly as well. It does take some nerve to try to recapture the essence of a childhood favorite (which are so much more sacred than books only loved as an adult), but it sounds like Motion pretty much carries it off.

    Good review.

  • Lucy Pollard-GottDecember 14, 2014 at 1:48 pm

    Nice to see another blogger give this book some attention! I really enjoyed it on balance too(my review:

    I concur with your estimation of the flawless start to the book and the adept use overall of well-placed references to Treasure Island. I absolutely agree with your singling out of the moment when young Jim meets the aging, infirm Long John Silver–even in his weakened state, Silver steals the book (only right he should do so!). I also agree with putting readers on notice that this isn’t a YA read because of violence, etc. Silver’s daughter is an intriguing character and does it enhance interest for female readers; however, Treasure Island has long been a favorite of mine and my daughter’s, so Stevenson himself knew how to reach readers, male and female.

    Thanks to JaneGS for letting me know about your great review!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

+ 24 = 29

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Social media & sharing icons powered by UltimatelySocial
Visit Us
Follow Me
Post on X